• If you are trying to reset your account password then don't forget to check spam folder in your mailbox. Also Mark it as "not spam" or you won't be able to click on the link.

★☆★ Xforum | Ultimate Story Contest 2023 ~ Reviews Thread ★☆★

Status
Not open for further replies.

Trinity

Staff member
Super-Moderator
6,115
4,399
219
Last date for posting reviews for the award of best reader is also increased, now you can post your reviews to feature in the best reader award till 15 th March 2023 11:59 Pm.You can also post your reviews After that deadline but they won't be counted for the best readers award. So Cheers.
 

Itachi_Uchiha

अंतःअस्ति प्रारंभः
7,840
27,281
204
Story :- Architect
Writer :- Werewolf

Positive points :- Kya hi jabardast story thi. Such me maja hi aa gaya. Jaisa mujhe aapse ummid thi aapne bilkul usi level ka story pesh kiya ? Story ka title bilkul perfect tha. Story ka concept bilkul hi naya tha. Story ka narration epic tha. Jo sound effect aap create karna cahte the aap usme 100 percent safal rahe. Story me suru se le kar ending tak thrill and suspence bhara pada tha. Bich me jo comedy ka tadka laga wo to bikul naya aur soch se hi pare tha. Story ki starting jitni beautiful thi ending utni hi kamal ki thi. Story read krte time laga hi nahi ki mai story read kr raha hu, mujhe aisa feel ho raha tha jaise mere samne screen par koi mast movie chal rahi hai.
Story read krte time mind kahi aur gaya hi nahi pura dhyan story ne kud ki taraf khiche rakha tha. Ab aage kya hoga bas yahi baat pure time man me chal rahi thi.
Mujhe aapke story ka best part jo laga wo tha jab aapne story ka end story ke starting se jis tarah connect kiya. Sari chije apne aap judti chli gayi. Sub kuch bina jyada kuch kahe aaps me connect ho gaya. Jabki mai ache se janta hu ye read krne me jitna simple lag raha hai iske bare me sochna aur ise likhna utna hi jyada muskil raha hoga.
Story ke sare kirdar almost to the point lage. Maa aur bete ke bich ka relationship, working person aur uske kaam me aani wali problem, dosto ke bich ka yarana, sub aapne bikul saral aur ache tarike se dikhaya hme.
Kehne ko to aur bhi bahut kuchh hai lakin mai aur jyada ab is bare me nahi kahunga.


Negative points :- Aapke story me mujhe bas kuch kami lagi aur wo ye thi ki
1. agar aapne thodi si details is bare me de di hoti ki wo goonga ye kaam kyu karta tha ? Aakhir uska past kya tha ?

2. " Ghar se achanak hi andhera kahi gaayab ho gaya. "
Aapne ye kaha, lakin goonga to abhi mara nahi to fir us aurat ka badla pura kaise hi gaya ? Bhale hi anjane me mara samay ne lakin isme mai hath to goonge ka tha, wo kyu bach gaya ?

3. Ye aurat jb mari usase phle hi us jagah ke horror kisse famous the ? To wo kiske the ? Goonge ne isase phle jinko mara tha unke ? Aapne is baat ka bhi jawab nahi diya.

Fir aapke story me do ekdam choti galtiya mili jise najarandaz kiya ja sakta hai. Lakin bas aapko dhyan dilane ke liye mai use yaha likh raha hu.
1. " Shaam ke 6 baj rahe the aur Samay apne ghar ki balcony par khade phone par baat kar raha tha. "
Yaha par aapne apne ghar ka prayog kiya, jisase mujhe thodi confusion hui. Jabki wo samay ka ghar nahi tha, balki samay waha rehta tha. To aapko yaha Samay jis ghar me rehta tha / Samay yaha jis ghar me rehta tha aise hi kisi word ka use karte to ye confusion nahi hota.

2. " Ek qadam, do qadam peeche lete hue wo deewaar se bhid gaya. "
Ab Door ke piche deewar kaha se aa gayi bhai ? Ab agar aap yaha ye kehte ki wo side ke deewar se takraya to baat smjh me aati.


Best dialogue :- " Apni sabse keemti meethi yaado ko sirf tasveero me hi nahi, apne dil me bhi rakhna chahiye.’

Taaki aane waale waqt me aap unke baare me soch apni yaadein taaza kar sake. "


Conclusion :- Jo kamiya mujhe lagi aur wo na hoti to mere hisab se no dought ye story USC 2023 ki no. 1 story hoti.
Fir bhi Overall mujhe aapki story bahut pasnd aayi. Aur mai ise winners ki list me jarur se jarur dekhna chahunga.
 
Last edited:

Itachi_Uchiha

अंतःअस्ति प्रारंभः
7,840
27,281
204
Story :- Indian Railways Fulfils Hubby’s Fantasy
Writer :- Clipmaster99

Positive points :-
Aapki story apne title ke hisab se bilkul sahi lagi. Title read krke hi pata chal raha hai ki aage kya hoga. Story me sare kirdar bhi thik thak lage mujhe. Story ki starting kafi achi thi. Story me kamukta bhi thik thak lagi. Amogh ek aisa pati tha jo apne wife ko kisi dusre person ke sath sex karte hue dekhna chahata tha. Aur aaj ke time me aisa kafi log hmare samaj me hi gaye hai jo aisi fantasy rakhte hai.
Aur jaha tak priya ki baat hai usko is baat ke liye raji karna koi mushkil kaam nahi tha. Quoi jaisa humne movies me dekha hai terorist logo ko roj roj ek hi chij ke bare me bata kar unka brainwashed kiya jata hai. Yaha priya ko manane me bhi usi tarike ka use hua hai. Aise me ek na an ek din priya ko manana tha hi. Mai aapke writing nd grammar knowledge ke liye ek extra point dena cahunga.


Negative points :-
" the blouse and into my bra and began to gently massage my boobs."
Jab priya ne Top pehna tha to yaha blouse kaha se aa gaya ?
Fir mujhe story ka 2nd half kuch jyada fast aur kam realistic laga. Agar Among sirf TT se setting karke ye sub kaam karta jo story jyada logical nd jyada realistic lagti. Jisase story ke 2nd part me jo sex scenes halka kamjor laga wo na hota.
Aur agar aapko 3som karna hi tha to waha baad me Among ki entry karwa dete to bhi problem nahi aati.


Best dialogue :-
" there is no limit to learning in sex and the more you have sex the more you want it. "

Conclusion :-
Khair overall mujhe aapki story Ek avg. Story se kahi jyada achi lagi. Lakin is story ka wo level nahi bana ki ye winners ki list me ho.
Ummid karta hu aage aap aur bhi ache topic ke sath hmare samne ek nayi story pesh karenge.
 

Itachi_Uchiha

अंतःअस्ति प्रारंभः
7,840
27,281
204
Story :- Breakup
Writer :- Mr. Magnificent

Positive points :-
Aapki story achi thi. Nidhi, Rahul ka kirdar bhi mujhe acha laga. Dono apne apne jagah bikul sahi lage. Aapki story aaj ke samaj ke kai sare couples ki story dikhati hai. Jaha Husband samjhta hai ki wo paiso se apne wife ki sari jarurte puri kar raha hai. Jise wo apni jimmedari puri samjhta hai. Lakin yahi to unki sbse badi bhool hoti hai. Aaj kal ke bhaag daur bhari jindagi me log apne wife ya family ko apna time hi to nahi de pate hai. Jabki aaj ke time me apno ke sath ki hi sbse jyada jarurt hoti hai. Aise me Nidhi ka piyush ke taraf jukhaw swabhavik hai. Aur baad me jab use ye pata chala ki Rahul, Mohini ke piche hai to use Rahul ko chorne ka ek bahana bhi mil gaya.

Negative points :-
Aapki story me bahut jagah word aur sentences me mistakes tha. Story ko read krte hue emotions jis hisab se feel hona cahiye tha waise feel nahi hue. Story ka title bhi mujhe uchit nahi laga. Quki sadi ka rista jab khtam hota hai to use Breakup to bikul nahi kaha ja sakta hai. Aur fir aapne story me kaha tha ki piyush un dono ko milane ka nishchay kiya lakin story me usne aisa koi prayas kiya ye to nahi dikha. Piyush ke role ke sath aap aur bhi bahut kuch dikha sakte the.

Best dialogue :-
" jindagi behte paani jaisi honi chahiye, hum uska bahaav control kar sakte hai to use ek jagah rok ke kharab kyu karna, jindagi ko jiyo use behne do. "

Conclusion :-
Aapki story ka concept to acha tha. Lakin story ko aapne sidhe sbdo me likha, jiske karan story me jyada emotions nahi aaye.
Overall aapki story mujhe ek avg. Story hi lagi. Ummid karta hu aage aap in bato ka dhyan rakhte hue hmare samne aur bhi achi story pesh karenge.
 

Itachi_Uchiha

अंतःअस्ति प्रारंभः
7,840
27,281
204
Story :- Gayab
Writer :- Mr. Magnificent

Positive points :-
Aapki story ka concept bikul naya aur bahut acha tha. Short story ke hisab se aapne ginti ke kirdar bhi rakhe. Mohan ka kirdar mujhe bahut acha laga. Ek scientist ke kirdar ke roop me aapne Mohan ko bikul sahi tarike se dikhaya. Story ka flow bhi bilkul sahi tha. Aur uski ending bhi kafi sahi lagi mujhe.

Negative points :-
Aapki 1st story ki tarah is story me bhi mujhe kahi kahi spellings aur sentence mistake dikhayi diye.human psychology aur criminal psychology do alg alg subject hai. Aapne dono ko ek hi bataya hai apne story me. Aur fir aapne ek jagah bataya ki Mohan aur Radhika library me criminal psychology se releted swalo ke jawab dundhte the. Aisi book aapko Law college me milengi. Ya jaha ye subject padhaya jata ho. But aapne story me is baat ke bare me kahi nahi bataya.
" Koi crime karte samay kisi criminal ki mansikta kya hoti hai iska Anubhav ab wo khud le raha tha.."
Ending me marte time wo kaise aisa feel kar skta hai. Ye baat mujhe to smjha me nahi aayi.


Best dialogue :-
waise to mujhe aapki is story me koi dilog best nahi laga. Fir bhi agar kuch likhna ho to mai is line ko best kahunga.
" hum bhi aise gayab ho sakte hai. "


Conclusion :-
Aapne is story ke jariye 2 muhavaro ko sahi sabit karte hue dikhaya hai.
1. Jaldi ka kaam saitan ka.
2. Jo dusro ke liye gaddha khoda karte hai wo kud usi gaddhe me gir jate hai.

Aapki story me jo kamiya mujhe lagi agar wo na hoti. Story thodi aur Logic hoti nd story ko aur ache sanwad ke sath aap pesh karte, to mujhe pura yakin tha ki aapki story winners ke list me jarur samil hoti.

Ummid karta hu aap in galtiyon se sikh le kar aage hmare samne aur achi achi story laate rahenge. Quki aapke ander likhne ki bahut kabiliyat hai.
 

Werewolf

𝕽𝖚𝖒𝖇𝖑𝖎𝖓𝖌
Supreme
18,575
115,042
259
Story :- Architect
Writer :- Werewolf

Positive points :- Kya hi jabardast story thi. Such me maja hi aa gaya. Jaisa mujhe aapse ummid thi aapne bilkul usi level ka story pesh kiya ? Story ka title bilkul perfect tha. Story ka concept bilkul hi naya tha. Story ka narration epic tha. Jo sound effect aap create karna cahte the aap usme 100 percent safal rahe. Story me suru se le kar ending tak thrill and suspence bhara pada tha. Bich me jo comedy ka tadka laga wo to bikul naya aur soch se hi pare tha. Story ki starting jitni beautiful thi ending utni hi kamal ki thi. Story read krte time laga hi nahi ki mai story read kr raha hu, mujhe aisa feel ho raha tha jaise mere samne screen par koi mast movie chal rahi hai.
Story read krte time mind kahi aur gaya hi nahi pura dhyan story ne kud ki taraf khiche rakha tha. Ab aage kya hoga bas yahi baat pure time man me chal rahi thi.
Mujhe aapke story ka best part jo laga wo tha jab aapne story ka end story ke starting se jis tarah connect kiya. Sari chije apne aap judti chli gayi. Sub kuch bina jyada kuch kahe aaps me connect ho gaya. Jabki mai ache se janta hu ye read krne me jitna simple lag raha hai iske bare me sochna aur ise likhna utna hi jyada muskil raha hoga.
Story ke sare kirdar almost to the point lage. Maa aur bete ke bich ka relationship, working person aur uske kaam me aani wali problem, dosto ke bich ka yarana, sub aapne bikul saral aur ache tarike se dikhaya hme.
Kehne ko to aur bhi bahut kuchh hai lakin mai aur jyada ab is bare me nahi kahunga.


Negative points :- Aapke story me mujhe bas kuch kami lagi aur wo ye thi ki
1. agar aapne thodi si details is bare me de di hoti ki wo goonga ye kaam kyu karta tha ? Aakhir uska past kya tha ?

2. " Ghar se achanak hi andhera kahi gaayab ho gaya. "
Aapne ye kaha, lakin goonga to abhi mara nahi to fir us aurat ka badla pura kaise hi gaya ? Bhale hi anjane me mara samay ne lakin isme mai hath to goonge ka tha, wo kyu bach gaya ?

3. Ye aurat jb mari usase phle hi us jagah ke horror kisse famous the ? To wo kiske the ? Goonge ne isase phle jinko mara tha unke ? Aapne is baat ka bhi jawab nahi diya.

Fir aapke story me do ekdam choti galtiya mili jise najarandaz kiya ja sakta hai. Lakin bas aapko dhyan dilane ke liye mai use yaha likh raha hu.
1. " Shaam ke 6 baj rahe the aur Samay apne ghar ki balcony par khade phone par baat kar raha tha. "
Yaha par aapne apne ghar ka prayog kiya, jisase mujhe thodi confusion hui. Jabki wo samay ka ghar nahi tha, balki samay waha rehta tha. To aapko yaha Samay jis ghar me rehta tha / Samay yaha jis ghar me rehta tha aise hi kisi word ka use karte to ye confusion nahi hota.

2. " Ek qadam, do qadam peeche lete hue wo deewaar se bhid gaya. "
Ab Door ke piche deewar kaha se aa gayi bhai ? Ab agar aap yaha ye kehte ki wo side ke deewar se takraya to baat smjh me aati.


Best dialogue :- " Apni sabse keemti meethi yaado ko sirf tasveero me hi nahi, apne dil me bhi rakhna chahiye.’

Taaki aane waale waqt me aap unke baare me soch apni yaadein taaza kar sake. "


Conclusion :- Jo kamiya mujhe lagi aur wo na hoti to mere hisab se no dought ye story USC 2023 ki no. 1 story hoti.
Fir bhi Overall mujhe aapki story bahut pasnd aayi. Aur mai ise winners ki list me jarur se jarur dekhna chahunga.
Bohut bohut dhanyavaad bhai! ✨
Aapke story me mujhe bas kuch kami lagi aur wo ye thi ki
1. agar aapne thodi si details is bare me de di hoti ki wo goonga ye kaam kyu karta tha ? Aakhir uska past kya tha ?
Goonga serial killer tha na. 7000 shabdo me sab kuch nahi dikhaya jaa sakta mitr. Harr kahani me yahi baat kahi jaa sakti hai. Ki iska thoda aur dikhana tha, woh thoda aur dikhana tha. Kintu 7000 shabdo me ye harr jagah possible nahi hota.
2. " Ghar se achanak hi andhera kahi gaayab ho gaya. "
Aapne ye kaha, lakin goonga to abhi mara nahi to fir us aurat ka badla pura kaise hi gaya ? Bhale hi anjane me mara samay ne lakin isme mai hath to goonge ka tha, wo kyu bach gaya ?
Kyuki aurat ne kabhi goonge ko dekha hi nahi. :declare: Kahani me ye mentioned hai. Dekha toh usne Samay ko bhi nahi tha. Kintu samay ne galti kar dii thi na. Woh pendant rakh kar. The entity sensed the pendant as soon as Samay came back to the town.
3. Ye aurat jb mari usase phle hi us jagah ke horror kisse famous the ? To wo kiske the ? Goonge ne isase phle jinko mara tha unke ? Aapne is baat ka bhi jawab nahi diya.
It's obvious ki ye sab racha gaya tha. Goonga uss place par jab karistaaniya kar raha tha toh zaahir hai woh sunishchit karega ki koi bhi yaha daakhil na ho. Bhay ka mahaul jaan boojh ke racha jaata tha. Afwaahe felana, awaazein cheekhe nikaalna.

Ye hints kahani me batayi nahi jaati. Khaas kar short stories me. Agar inka description likhne baithenge, inhe explain karenge toh plot kab dikhaya jayega? Reader kitni jaldi open mind se catch karta hai, ye uske upar hota hai. Mujhe khushi hai ki ju ne openly iss genre ko, khaas kar bhoot pret ko acche se accept kiya hai.
Fir aapke story me do ekdam choti galtiya mili jise najarandaz kiya ja sakta hai. Lakin bas aapko dhyan dilane ke liye mai use yaha likh raha hu.
1. " Shaam ke 6 baj rahe the aur Samay apne ghar ki balcony par khade phone par baat kar raha tha. "
Yaha par aapne apne ghar ka prayog kiya, jisase mujhe thodi confusion hui. Jabki wo samay ka ghar nahi tha, balki samay waha rehta tha. To aapko yaha Samay jis ghar me rehta tha / Samay yaha jis ghar me rehta tha aise hi kisi word ka use karte to ye confusion nahi hota
Isme confusion hua? :laugh: Ye mene expect na kiya tha. Agar ek aadmi kiraaye ke ghar pe reh raha ho. Woh kisi mehmaan ko pick up karne station gaya ho. Toh woh apne mehmaan se kya kahega?

Ye ki, "aaiye chaliye, mein aapko apne ghar le chalta hu."

Ya fir ye, "aaiye chaliye, mein aapko apne kiraaye ke ghar le chalta hu."

Ju ko uttar pata hi hoga. :smile2: Words ghatane hote hai. Badhaane nahi. Kahani wese hi 6993 words ke aas paas ki thi. Risk nahi le sakte aap.
2. " Ek qadam, do qadam peeche lete hue wo deewaar se bhid gaya. "
Ab Door ke piche deewar kaha se aa gayi bhai ? Ab agar aap yaha ye kehte ki wo side ke deewar se takraya to baat smjh me aati.
Imagine nahi kar paaye shayad ju bhai. Mein wo bhi karwaye deta hu.

Example le lete hai hum. Doraemon toh dekha hi hoga ju ne. Usme nobita ka kamra bhi dekha hi hoga.

Maan lo ki uske kamre ki khidki Samay ke ghar ka darwaza hai. Ab aise me Samay agar darr ke peeche jaata hai toh woh kis se bhidega? Deewaar se. :declare: Hallway seedha ghus ke nahi tha. Turn leke hai.

Kahani ko likhte samay actual me mene ek apartment ke nakshe ko dhyaan me rakh ke likha hai. Mera mitr rehta hai ek building me. Uska flat hai. Udhar ke nakshe ko dhyaan me rakh ke hi likha gaya hai sab. Befaaltu mann se kahi bhi koi deewaar nahi banayi gayi hai.
Best dialogue :- " Apni sabse keemti meethi yaado ko sirf tasveero me hi nahi, apne dil me bhi rakhna chahiye.’

Taaki aane waale waqt me aap unke baare me soch apni yaadein taaza kar sake. "
Ye best dialogue laga ju ko. Badhiya hai. Waise mera favourite wo wala tha. Samay ko samay ne hi barbaad kar diya. Aur ek wo wala. He was the sole architect of her destruction. :smile2:
Conclusion :- Jo kamiya mujhe lagi aur wo na hoti to mere hisab se no dought ye story USC 2023 ki no. 1 story hoti.
Fir bhi Overall mujhe aapki story bahut pasnd aayi. Aur mai ise winners ki list me jarur se jarur dekhna chahunga.
Dhanyavaad bhaaya. ✨
Keep supporting! ✨
 

Clipmaster99

Winner of Award - "No.1 Contributor to XForum"
Staff member
Moderator
127,260
261,649
339
Story :- Indian Railways Fulfils Hubby’s Fantasy
Writer :- Clipmaster99

Positive points :- Aapki story apne title ke hisab se bilkul sahi lagi. Title read krke hi pata chal raha hai ki aage kya hoga. Story me sare kirdar bhi thik thak lage mujhe. Story ki starting kafi achi thi. Story me kamukta bhi thik thak lagi. Amogh ek aisa pati tha jo apne wife ko kisi dusre person ke sath sex karte hue dekhna chahata tha. Aur aaj ke time me aisa kafi log hmare samaj me hi gaye hai jo aisi fantasy rakhte hai.
Aur jaha tak priya ki baat hai usko is baat ke liye raji karna koi mushkil kaam nahi tha. Quoi jaisa humne movies me dekha hai terorist logo ko roj roj ek hi chij ke bare me bata kar unka brainwashed kiya jata hai. Yaha priya ko manane me bhi usi tarike ka use hua hai. Aise me ek na an ek din priya ko manana tha hi. Mai aapke writing nd grammar knowledge ke liye ek extra point dena cahunga.


Negative points :- " the blouse and into my bra and began to gently massage my boobs."
Jab priya ne Top pehna tha to yaha blouse kaha se aa gaya ?
Fir mujhe story ka 2nd half kuch jyada fast aur kam realistic laga. Agar Among sirf TT se setting karke ye sub kaam karta jo story jyada logical nd jyada realistic lagti. Jisase story ke 2nd part me jo sex scenes halka kamjor laga wo na hota.
Aur agar aapko 3som karna hi tha to waha baad me Among ki entry karwa dete to bhi problem nahi aati.


Best dialogue :- " there is no limit to learning in sex and the more you have sex the more you want it. "

Conclusion :- Khair overall mujhe aapki story Ek avg. Story se kahi jyada achi lagi. Lakin is story ka wo level nahi bana ki ye winners ki list me ho.
Ummid karta hu aage aap aur bhi ache topic ke sath hmare samne ek nayi story pesh karenge.
Itachi_Uchiha

Since my Story is in English, I shall answer your Review in English. Hinglish is not my forte.

Firstly, Thank-you for taking the time to review my story.


While a Title should be a bit mysterious, it should also give a hint of what to expect in the story. The Reader is set on course to learn what unfolds in the story referencing the title.


“Aur aaj ke time me aisa kafi log hmare samaj me hi gaye hai jo aisi fantasy rakhte hai”.

This line reflects your moralistic views with blinkers. Approach a story with an open mind. A story does not have to match your dogmas.

“Quoi jaisa humne movies me dekha hai terorist logo ko roj roj ek hi chij ke bare me bata kar unka brainwashed kiya jata hai.”

Once again, this statement reflects your narrow dogmas. There is no comparison between a terrorist and a sexual fantasy. Like in the movies, do movies reflect life? Or does life copy what is shown in movies?

But let me pay attention to your Negative points.

What makes a top a blouse? (Check Google)

A blouse is defined as a loose-fitting upper garment worn by women. A blouse gathers at the waist or hips so that it hangs loosely over the body. Over time, the term has been used to refer to a shirt that has an unmistakably feminine appearance.

Your grouse that the second part was rushed through is ill-conceived. When you write for a short story competition, you need to balance the story within the limits of the prescribed words. The introduction of the characters and the setting is as important as the final stages as the story builds up to its climax.

I would like to point out that many Readers have written to me that they personally liked the “group sex”. If you have read the story carefully, you would have noticed that there was a video made. It is not possible to do that if only two people are involved in the sex. The blindfold was for that reason.


Let us wait for the Conclusion and decision of the Judges.
 

Clipmaster99

Winner of Award - "No.1 Contributor to XForum"
Staff member
Moderator
127,260
261,649
339
My thoughts about

Title: Indian Railways Fulfils Hubby’s Fantasy

Author: Clipmaster 99


1st of all, I am in no way qualified to post a review for any story, since I have very particular likings and dislikes, and anything out of that zone is not going to touch my heart and mind, therefore impartial review is not possible.
Even then since the writer asked me to read his story, I am registering my comments on that, not as a critic or the reviewer, but as a person who happens to be in touch with housewives who got a somewhat adventurous lifestyle.
Many of you haven't noticed that basically, I am an Xclusive poster for the adult section of XF, and I am the photographer for a few married girls who dared to bare it all in front of my camera. Though few of them hide these from their husband, few of their hubby enjoys the photo session and are present during the event. Particularly during outdoor shoots.
On many occasions, accidents happen and maybe a fisherman or a stranger could steal a look at their nudity, at first they get scared and spoil the mood for the day but after one or two incidences they are now quite daring and not shy to expose even in the risky situations.
Now, when your story dealt with a similar kind of experience and fantasy, I could very well relate to that, and your narration made it easier for me. Narration wise it was fantastic and I liked how you kept it subtle and left a few for our imagination.
The story talked about the transformation of a shy homely girl to a raunchy plaything, which she likes, it was smooth and felt normal.
The excitement part was also fine IMO.
The character buildups for the main protagonist were nicely done.
The language was perfect.
The story name could have been better, can't think of any now, but will let you know if something comes to mind.

All the best for the contest.

psychoknight

My sincere Thanks for making time to post a review of my story. You have been very humble to say that you are not qualified to give a review. I do not think so. As a story writer yourself, you are aware of the nuances that a Story writer needs to possess.

What struck me, was your non-judgemental attitude and your willingness to allow others to have their point of view, even if you don't concur with them.

You have a very mature view of Life and from your comments above, obviously, you have seen facets of how the female mind works. BTW, the story is an experience of a female friend who narrated it to me and I garnished it with some masala here.

Thank you once again for all the positive feedback and your good wishes for the Contest.

Fingers crossed.

🤞


 
Last edited:

Itachi_Uchiha

अंतःअस्ति प्रारंभः
7,840
27,281
204
Story :- ❌Double Cross❌
Writer :- Adirshi

Positive points :-
Thrill se puri bhari hui ye mujhe 1st story mili. Jaha suru se le kar ant tak pura focas watch ke upar hi raha. Apki story likhne ka level alag hi hai bhai. Kya story likhi hai maja hi aa gaya. Normally short story me aap limited kirdar aur jyada scene change nahi karte hai. Quik isase Short story me bahut sare confusion create ho Jate hai. Lakin aapke upar ye rule laghu nahi hota hai.
Aapne apne is short story me Itne sare kirdar rakhe. Sayad meri read ki gayi abhi tak ki sari SS me sbse jyada. Lakin fir bhi kisi bhi kirdar ko yaad rakhne me bikul bhi paresani ka samna karna nahi pada. Jo ki is story ki pehli sbse important baat thi.
Uske baad aapne hme Film start ke ghar se le kar, film City, hotal, malesiya, police station, bar aur na jane kaha kaha ghuma diya. Lakin ek bhi scene transfer ke samay bilkul bhi problem nahi aayi. Sub bilkul smooth ho gaya. Ye thi aapki story ki 2nd sbse important baat. Uske alawa aapne is ek story me aur bhi bahut kuchh dikhaya. Sare dialogue bilkul situation aur kirdar ke hisab se best lage. Story ka narration jabardast tha. concept bhi bikul naya tha. Wo shemale wala scene bhi kafi surprising aur acha tha. Kehne ko to aur bhi bahut kuchh hai lakin mai ab aur kuch nahi kahunga quki jyada time nahi hai na best reader wala dibba jo jitna hai😁.


Negative points :-
sbse phli baat story ka title story se match nahi kiya. Title isase kafi behtar ho skta tha. Dusri baat Aapne Sashi ki maa ki bich me baat ki. Lakin unke bich manmutav kyu hai ye nahi bataya ?
Fir movie ko aapne almost 90 min me hi khtam kar diya. Ye baat mujhe halki kataki.


Best dialogue :-
" bade logo ki baat ki kuch aur hoti hain a unke sab kaam jaldi ho jate hai. "

Conclusion :-
kul mila kar aapki story agar count hoti to mai ise winners ke list me jarur dekhna chahata.
Aap ke writing ka mai fan ho gaya hu. Apne fan list me ab mujhe bhi add kar lijiyega.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top