• If you are trying to reset your account password then don't forget to check spam folder in your mailbox. Also Mark it as "not spam" or you won't be able to click on the link.

★☆★ Xforum | Ultimate Story Contest 2025 ~ Reviews Thread ★☆★

Lucifer

ReFiCuL
Staff member
Co-Admin
9,998
10,684
314
Unfortunately We are facing a server issue which limits most users from posting long posts which is very necessary for USC entries as all of them are above 5-7K words ,we are fixing this issue as I post this but it'll take few days so keeping this in mind the last date of entry thread is increased once again,Entry thread will be closed on 7th May 11:59 PM. And you can still post reviews for best reader's award till 13th May 11:59 PM. Sorry for the inconvenience caused.

You can PM your story to any mod and they'll post it for you.

Note to writers :- Don't try to post long updates instead post it in 2 Or more posts. Thanks. Regards :- Luci
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Aakash.

ɪ'ᴍ ᴜꜱᴇᴅ ᴛᴏ ʙᴇ ꜱᴡᴇᴇᴛ ᴀꜱ ꜰᴜᴄᴋ, ɴᴏᴡ ɪᴛ'ꜱ ꜰᴜᴄᴋ & ꜰᴜᴄᴋ
Staff member
Sr. Moderator
50,943
163,122
354
"Ek Cyber Katha" by RED Ashoka

Thrilling cyber crime kahani hai jo Aditya Raj naam ke ek young aur talented hacker ke ird-gird ghumti hai. Kahani mein Aditya ka safar dikhaya gaya hai jo ek international crime syndicate The Black Vault ko expose aur hara deta hai apni cyber skills aur dimaagi strategy ke bal par. Yeh kahani technology, suspense aur strategic thinking ka ek rochak mishran hai.

Positive Points:

▪︎ Kahani ka Plot: Kahani ka concept modern aur engaging hai. Cyber-crime aur digital forensics jaise topics aaj ke digital yug mein relevant hain jo readers ko instantly connect karta hai. Aditya ka The Black Vault ke khilaaf akela ladna ek heroic vibe deta hai.

▪︎ Character Development: Aditya ka character well-crafted hai. Uska intelligence, patience aur strategic thinking kahani ko aur mazboot karta hai. Anil Khurana jaisa villain bhi mysterious aur dangerous laga jo suspense banaye rakhta hai.

▪︎ Suspense aur Pace: Kahani mein suspense ka level acha hai khaas kar jab Aditya Black Vault ke network mein ghusne ki koshish karta hai ya Khurana ke saath double game khelta hai har step ke saath curiosity badhti hai.

▪︎ Technical Details: Cyber security, encryption, backdoor access jaise technical aspects ko simple bhasha mein explain kiya gaya hai jo non-technical readers ke liye bhi samajhna asaan hai.

▪︎ Moral: Kahani ka message buddhi aur strategy se bade se bada dushman haraya ja sakta hai inspiring hai.

Negative Points:

▪︎ Predictable Ending: Kahani ka climax thoda predictable hai. Aditya ka Khurana ko hara dena aur authorities ko saboot dena ek common trope lagta hai jo thoda fresh ho sakta tha.

▪︎ Supporting Characters ki Kami: Aditya ke alawa koi aur strong character nahi hai. Black Vault ke aur members ya Aditya ke allies ko thoda explore kiya ja sakta tha taaki kahani aur layered ho.

▪︎ Emotional Connect ki Kami: Kahani mein Aditya ke personal life ya emotions ko zyada dikhaya nahi gaya jisse readers ko uske saath emotional bonding banane mein thodi dikkat ho sakti hai.

▪︎ Over-Simplified Villain: Khurana ek dangerous villain hai lekin uski backstory ya motives ke baare mein zyada nahi bataya gaya jisse wo thoda one-dimensional laga.

Ek Acchi Kahani ke Liye Kya Accha aur Kya Bura Hai:

▪︎ Accha: Ek acchi kahani mein strong central character, engaging plot aur unexpected twists hona zaroori hai us kahani mein Aditya ka character aur cyber-crime ka concept yeh qualities puri karta hai. Simple bhasha aur suspense bhi plus point hain.

▪︎ Bura: Kahani ko aur gehraai dene ke liye supporting characters, emotional depth aur unpredictable climax zaroori hota hai us kahani mein yeh thoda missing hai. Villain ke motives ko bhi aur explore karna chahiye tha.

Wartani aur Rhythm:

▪︎ Wartani: Kahani ki bhasha simple aur roman Hindi mein hai jo padhne mein asaan hai. Kuch jagah par shabdon ka dohrav thoda zyada laga Spelling mein koi major galti nahi hai.

▪︎ Rhythm: Kahani ka flow acha hai khaas kar action aur suspense scenes mein lekin kuch parts jaise Khurana ke heist ki taiyari thoda slow lage. Introduction aur climax ke beech ka balance thoda aur tight ho sakta tha.

Overall:

Ek entertaining aur modern kahani hai jo cyber-crime ke fans ke liye acchi hai. Aditya ka intelligence aur strategy kahani ko dilchasp banata hai lekin thoda emotional depth aur unpredictable twists isse aur behtar bana sakte the. Wartani simple aur rhythm bhi acha hai bas thoda polishing ki zarurat hai.
 

RED Ashoka

Writer
745
1,000
124
"Ek Cyber Katha" by RED Ashoka

Thrilling cyber crime kahani hai jo Aditya Raj naam ke ek young aur talented hacker ke ird-gird ghumti hai. Kahani mein Aditya ka safar dikhaya gaya hai jo ek international crime syndicate The Black Vault ko expose aur hara deta hai apni cyber skills aur dimaagi strategy ke bal par. Yeh kahani technology, suspense aur strategic thinking ka ek rochak mishran hai.

Positive Points:

▪︎ Kahani ka Plot: Kahani ka concept modern aur engaging hai. Cyber-crime aur digital forensics jaise topics aaj ke digital yug mein relevant hain jo readers ko instantly connect karta hai. Aditya ka The Black Vault ke khilaaf akela ladna ek heroic vibe deta hai.

▪︎ Character Development: Aditya ka character well-crafted hai. Uska intelligence, patience aur strategic thinking kahani ko aur mazboot karta hai. Anil Khurana jaisa villain bhi mysterious aur dangerous laga jo suspense banaye rakhta hai.

▪︎ Suspense aur Pace: Kahani mein suspense ka level acha hai khaas kar jab Aditya Black Vault ke network mein ghusne ki koshish karta hai ya Khurana ke saath double game khelta hai har step ke saath curiosity badhti hai.

▪︎ Technical Details: Cyber security, encryption, backdoor access jaise technical aspects ko simple bhasha mein explain kiya gaya hai jo non-technical readers ke liye bhi samajhna asaan hai.

▪︎ Moral: Kahani ka message buddhi aur strategy se bade se bada dushman haraya ja sakta hai inspiring hai.

Negative Points:

▪︎ Predictable Ending: Kahani ka climax thoda predictable hai. Aditya ka Khurana ko hara dena aur authorities ko saboot dena ek common trope lagta hai jo thoda fresh ho sakta tha.

▪︎ Supporting Characters ki Kami: Aditya ke alawa koi aur strong character nahi hai. Black Vault ke aur members ya Aditya ke allies ko thoda explore kiya ja sakta tha taaki kahani aur layered ho.

▪︎ Emotional Connect ki Kami: Kahani mein Aditya ke personal life ya emotions ko zyada dikhaya nahi gaya jisse readers ko uske saath emotional bonding banane mein thodi dikkat ho sakti hai.

▪︎ Over-Simplified Villain: Khurana ek dangerous villain hai lekin uski backstory ya motives ke baare mein zyada nahi bataya gaya jisse wo thoda one-dimensional laga.

Ek Acchi Kahani ke Liye Kya Accha aur Kya Bura Hai:

▪︎ Accha: Ek acchi kahani mein strong central character, engaging plot aur unexpected twists hona zaroori hai us kahani mein Aditya ka character aur cyber-crime ka concept yeh qualities puri karta hai. Simple bhasha aur suspense bhi plus point hain.

▪︎ Bura: Kahani ko aur gehraai dene ke liye supporting characters, emotional depth aur unpredictable climax zaroori hota hai us kahani mein yeh thoda missing hai. Villain ke motives ko bhi aur explore karna chahiye tha.

Wartani aur Rhythm:

▪︎ Wartani: Kahani ki bhasha simple aur roman Hindi mein hai jo padhne mein asaan hai. Kuch jagah par shabdon ka dohrav thoda zyada laga Spelling mein koi major galti nahi hai.

▪︎ Rhythm: Kahani ka flow acha hai khaas kar action aur suspense scenes mein lekin kuch parts jaise Khurana ke heist ki taiyari thoda slow lage. Introduction aur climax ke beech ka balance thoda aur tight ho sakta tha.

Overall:


Ek entertaining aur modern kahani hai jo cyber-crime ke fans ke liye acchi hai. Aditya ka intelligence aur strategy kahani ko dilchasp banata hai lekin thoda emotional depth aur unpredictable twists isse aur behtar bana sakte the. Wartani simple aur rhythm bhi acha hai bas thoda polishing ki zarurat hai.
Shukriya :hi:
 

satrangi muniya

New Member
17
55
13
कहानी समीक्षा: जीवों का करुण क्रँदन
लेखिका महोदया: satrangi muniya

JKKK-SM2

यह कहानी बहुत ही नवीन और अलग तरह की रचना है। इसकी कल्पना थोड़ी असामान्य है, लेकिन वही इसे बेहद दिलचस्प बनाती है। पढ़ते-पढ़ते एक पल के लिए ऐसा लगता है मानो हम अपने बचपन के उन दिनों में लौट आए हैं, जब ऐसी मासूम मगर गहरी कहानियाँ किताबों में पढ़ते थे और उनकी दुनिया में खो जाया करते थे।

सतरंगी मुनिया जी ने इस कहानी में पंखों वाले जीवों और जंगल के वाशिंदों के माध्यम से एक ऐसी पुकार रच दी है, जो इंसानी सभ्यता के विकास की आड़ में हो रही तबाही का सजीव चित्र खींचती है। मोरनी सुनीता, तोती वीना, चतुरसेन बंदर, दुर्गम सिंह शेर... हर किरदार जैसे इस धरती के असली मालिकों का प्रतिनिधि बनकर सामने आता है।

कहानी का दर्द, संवादों की सहजता में रच-बसकर ऐसा बहता है कि कई बार रुक कर सांस लेनी पड़ती है। वीना की निरीह पुकार, दुर्गम सिंह का विवेक, चतुरसेन का सुझाव.. सब कुछ दिल को छू जाता है। ऐसा लगता नहीं कि कोई कथा पढ़ रहे हैं, बल्कि जैसे जंगल के बीच बैठकर खुद उनकी मीटिंग सुन रहे हैं। भाषा में सजीवता और भावनाओं का बहाव गजब है। बिना भाषण दिए, कहानी खुद सवाल उठा देती है.. ‘किसका हक़ ज़्यादा है इस धरती पर?’ बिना ओवरड्रामैटिक हुए, जानवरों को ऐसी मासूम सोच दी गई है कि पढ़ने वाला इंसान भी खुद को उनके बराबर खड़ा महसूस करे। सोशल मीडिया, कोर्ट स्टे, अंतर्राष्ट्रीय संस्थाएं.. कहानी आधुनिक ज़माने से भी जुड़ी हुई है, जो इसे आज के पाठक के लिए प्रासंगिक बनाती है।

कुछ सुझाव:

कहीं-कहीं संवाद थोड़ा दोहराव लिए हुए हैं (जैसे मोरनी और तोती के बीच चिंता व्यक्त करने के तरीके)। थोड़ा कसाव होता तो कहानी और ज्यादा तीखी बन सकती थी। कुछ चरित्रों का और गहरा चित्रण हो सकता था.. जैसे भीम अजगर का संवाद एकबारगी हल्का-फुल्का बनकर रह गया, जबकि उसमें भी डर और व्यंग्य का एक गहरा स्तर लाया जा सकता था।

अंतिम निष्कर्ष:

"जीवों का करुण क्रंदन" कोई साधारण कहानी नहीं है। यह एक जिंदा दस्तावेज़ है उस मौन त्रासदी का, जो हम इंसान हर दिन करते हैं और फिर अनदेखा कर देते हैं। सतरंगी मुनिया ने अपने शब्दों से एक पूरा जंगल जिंदा कर दिया है... उनकी आवाज़ हमारे कानों में न सही पर हमारी आत्मा में जरूर गूंजती है।
धन्यवाद वखारिया सर आपने मुझ जैसी नई लेखिका की कहानी पर कमेंट किया. जहाँ बात हर किरदार को समय देने की है तो ये कहानी छोटी थी इसलिए हरेक को थोड़ा थोड़ा रोल दे दिया. बाकी कुल मिलाकर आपने मेरी कहानी का इतना सुन्दर चित्रण क़र डाला कि मन ख़ुश हो गया. ये कहानी मैंने हैदराबाद में जंगल कटाई वाली घटना पर लिखी क्यूंकि उस घटना ने मेरे कोमल ह्रदय पर बहुत गहरा असर डाला. एक बार फिर से धन्यवाद सर 🙏🙏चित्र बहुत सुन्दर छापा आपने 😊
 

Aakash.

ɪ'ᴍ ᴜꜱᴇᴅ ᴛᴏ ʙᴇ ꜱᴡᴇᴇᴛ ᴀꜱ ꜰᴜᴄᴋ, ɴᴏᴡ ɪᴛ'ꜱ ꜰᴜᴄᴋ & ꜰᴜᴄᴋ
Staff member
Sr. Moderator
50,943
163,122
354
"Chanakya - Akhand Bharat" by RED Ashoka

Prernadayak aur historical fiction kahani hai jo Chanakya (Radhagupta) aur uske shishya Shaurya ke safar ko darshati hai. Yeh kahani Nand vansh ke atyachar ke khilaf ek sena banane aur ek naye nyaaypurna Bharat ke nirman ki baat karti hai. Kahani mein buddhi, neeti aur deshbhakti ka mishran hai jo Bharat ke ekikaran ka sapna dikhati hai.

Positive Points:

▪︎ Inspiring Theme: Kahani ka kendriya vichar buddhi aur neeti se ek nyaypurna samaj banaya ja sakta hai bohot prernadayak hai. Chanakya ka sankalp aur Shaurya ka utsah dil ko chhuta hai.

▪︎ Strong Characters: Chanakya ka character intelligent, strategic aur inspirational hai. Uska transformation ek sadharan brahman se Bharat ke sutradhar tak kahani ko gehrai deta hai. Shaurya bhi ek promising yuva yoddha ke roop mein ubharta hai.

▪︎ Historical Vibe: Kahani mein Takshashila, rajneeti, arthashastra aur yudh ki baatein historical context deti hain jo isse authentic feel karati hain.

▪︎ Descriptive Narration: Vijaypura ki galiyan, peepal ka ped aur rajmahal ke scenes vivid aur engaging hain. Yeh descriptions jo kahani ke liye accha hai.

▪︎ Message of Unity: Bharat ke ekikaran ka sapna aur "Satyameva Jayate" ka sandesh kahani ko ek universal appeal deta hai jo aaj bhi relevant hai.

Negative Points:

▪︎ Overly Idealistic: Kahani thodi idealistic lagti hai khaas kar jab gaon wale aur vanvasi itni jaldi Chanakya ke saath jud jate hain yeh thoda unrealistic sa laga.

▪︎ Supporting Characters ka Kam Vikas: Shaurya aur Chanakya ke alawa doosre characters jaise Bheemsen ya Virasena zyada developed nahi hain. Unki backstory ya motivations ko aur dikhaya ja sakta tha.

▪︎ Predictable Plot Points: Nand ka apmaan aur akhir mein haarna ya Shaurya ka samrat banana thoda formulaic laga thodi aur unpredictability plot ko aur rochak bana sakti thi.

▪︎ Pace Mein Kami: Kahani ke kuch hisse jaise sena banane ka process thoda repetitive aur slow lage jo flow ko affect karta hai.

Ek Acchi Kahani ke Liye Kya Accha aur Kya Bura Hai:

▪︎ Accha: Ek acchi kahani mein strong central characters, inspiring message aur vivid storytelling zaroori hai. Is kahani mein Chanakya ka vision, Shaurya ka utsah aur Bharat ke ekikaran ka sapna yeh qualities puri karta hai. Simple bhasha aur deshbhakti ka jazba bhi iski taakat hain.

▪︎ Bura: Kahani ko aur engaging banane ke liye supporting characters ka vikas thoda unpredictability aur tight pacing zaroori hai. Is kahani mein yeh thoda missing hai. Villain (Nand) ke motives ya complexity ko bhi aur explore kiya ja sakta tha.

Wartani aur Rhythm:

▪︎ Wartani: Kahani ki bhasha simple aur roman Hindi mein hai jo padhne mein asaan hai. Shabd chayan descriptive aur impactful hai khaas kar Chanakya ke dialogues mein. Kuch jagah par shabdon ka dohrav thoda zyada laga. Spelling mein koi major galti nahi hai.

▪︎ Rhythm: Kahani ka flow shuruaat mein acha hai khaas kar Chanakya ke apmaan aur Shaurya se milne wale scenes mein lekin sena banane aur yudh ki taiyari wale parts thoda stretched lage jisse pace slow hui. Climax powerful hai lekin thoda jaldi wrap-up ho gaya.

Final Thoughts:

Prernadayak aur deshbhakti se bhari kahani hai jo Chanakya ke vision aur neeti ko sundar dhang se pesh karti hai. Yeh historical fiction ke fans ke liye ek acchi kahani hai lekin thodi aur character depth aur unpredictable twists isse aur behtar bana sakte the. Wartani vivid aur rhythm bhi acha hai bas pacing mein thodi improvement ki zarurat hai.
 

RED Ashoka

Writer
745
1,000
124
"Chanakya - Akhand Bharat" by RED Ashoka

Prernadayak aur historical fiction kahani hai jo Chanakya (Radhagupta) aur uske shishya Shaurya ke safar ko darshati hai. Yeh kahani Nand vansh ke atyachar ke khilaf ek sena banane aur ek naye nyaaypurna Bharat ke nirman ki baat karti hai. Kahani mein buddhi, neeti aur deshbhakti ka mishran hai jo Bharat ke ekikaran ka sapna dikhati hai.

Positive Points:

▪︎ Inspiring Theme: Kahani ka kendriya vichar buddhi aur neeti se ek nyaypurna samaj banaya ja sakta hai bohot prernadayak hai. Chanakya ka sankalp aur Shaurya ka utsah dil ko chhuta hai.

▪︎ Strong Characters: Chanakya ka character intelligent, strategic aur inspirational hai. Uska transformation ek sadharan brahman se Bharat ke sutradhar tak kahani ko gehrai deta hai. Shaurya bhi ek promising yuva yoddha ke roop mein ubharta hai.

▪︎ Historical Vibe: Kahani mein Takshashila, rajneeti, arthashastra aur yudh ki baatein historical context deti hain jo isse authentic feel karati hain.

▪︎ Descriptive Narration: Vijaypura ki galiyan, peepal ka ped aur rajmahal ke scenes vivid aur engaging hain. Yeh descriptions jo kahani ke liye accha hai.

▪︎ Message of Unity: Bharat ke ekikaran ka sapna aur "Satyameva Jayate" ka sandesh kahani ko ek universal appeal deta hai jo aaj bhi relevant hai.

Negative Points:

▪︎ Overly Idealistic: Kahani thodi idealistic lagti hai khaas kar jab gaon wale aur vanvasi itni jaldi Chanakya ke saath jud jate hain yeh thoda unrealistic sa laga.

▪︎ Supporting Characters ka Kam Vikas: Shaurya aur Chanakya ke alawa doosre characters jaise Bheemsen ya Virasena zyada developed nahi hain. Unki backstory ya motivations ko aur dikhaya ja sakta tha.

▪︎ Predictable Plot Points: Nand ka apmaan aur akhir mein haarna ya Shaurya ka samrat banana thoda formulaic laga thodi aur unpredictability plot ko aur rochak bana sakti thi.

▪︎ Pace Mein Kami: Kahani ke kuch hisse jaise sena banane ka process thoda repetitive aur slow lage jo flow ko affect karta hai.

Ek Acchi Kahani ke Liye Kya Accha aur Kya Bura Hai:

▪︎ Accha: Ek acchi kahani mein strong central characters, inspiring message aur vivid storytelling zaroori hai. Is kahani mein Chanakya ka vision, Shaurya ka utsah aur Bharat ke ekikaran ka sapna yeh qualities puri karta hai. Simple bhasha aur deshbhakti ka jazba bhi iski taakat hain.

▪︎ Bura: Kahani ko aur engaging banane ke liye supporting characters ka vikas thoda unpredictability aur tight pacing zaroori hai. Is kahani mein yeh thoda missing hai. Villain (Nand) ke motives ya complexity ko bhi aur explore kiya ja sakta tha.

Wartani aur Rhythm:

▪︎ Wartani: Kahani ki bhasha simple aur roman Hindi mein hai jo padhne mein asaan hai. Shabd chayan descriptive aur impactful hai khaas kar Chanakya ke dialogues mein. Kuch jagah par shabdon ka dohrav thoda zyada laga. Spelling mein koi major galti nahi hai.

▪︎ Rhythm: Kahani ka flow shuruaat mein acha hai khaas kar Chanakya ke apmaan aur Shaurya se milne wale scenes mein lekin sena banane aur yudh ki taiyari wale parts thoda stretched lage jisse pace slow hui. Climax powerful hai lekin thoda jaldi wrap-up ho gaya.

Final Thoughts:


Prernadayak aur deshbhakti se bhari kahani hai jo Chanakya ke vision aur neeti ko sundar dhang se pesh karti hai. Yeh historical fiction ke fans ke liye ek acchi kahani hai lekin thodi aur character depth aur unpredictable twists isse aur behtar bana sakte the. Wartani vivid aur rhythm bhi acha hai bas pacing mein thodi improvement ki zarurat hai.
Thankyou
Aapke points jarur dhyan rakhen jayenge
Kahani ko samajhne ke liye dhanywaad :hi:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Shetan and Avaran

Aakash.

ɪ'ᴍ ᴜꜱᴇᴅ ᴛᴏ ʙᴇ ꜱᴡᴇᴇᴛ ᴀꜱ ꜰᴜᴄᴋ, ɴᴏᴡ ɪᴛ'ꜱ ꜰᴜᴄᴋ & ꜰᴜᴄᴋ
Staff member
Sr. Moderator
50,943
163,122
354
"Ek Nayi Shuruaat" by RED Ashoka

Dilchasp kahani hai jo romance aur suspense ka milaap hai. Neha aur Aarav ki shaadi ki raat se shuru hokar yeh kahani ek dramatic twist ke saath ek mysterious bache ke raaz tak jati hai. Pyaar, vishwas aur ek anjaan sach ke ird-gird ghumti yeh kahani readers ko ek emotional aur thrilling safar par le jati hai.

Positive Points:

▪︎ Captivating Start: Kahani ki shuruaat bohot strong hai jahan shaadi ki raat ka romantic moment ek gunshot ke saath suspenseful ho jata hai. Yeh opening scene readers ko turant jod deta hai.

▪︎ Relatable Characters: Neha aur Aarav ka rishta bohot sundar aur natural dikhaya gaya hai. Unka ek doosre ke prati pyaar aur samajhdari kahani mein emotional connect banati hai.

▪︎ Mystery Element: Bache ka sudden appearance aur uska connection Aarav ke purane dost se ek intriguing twist deta hai jo kahani ko unpredictable banata hai.

▪︎ Short and Focused: Kahani compact hai jo ek quick aur engaging reading ke liye perfect hai har scene plot ko aage badhata hai jisse boredom nahi hota.

▪︎ Message of Strength: Neha aur Aarav ka saath mein sach dhundhne ka junoon dikhata hai ki mushkil halat mein bhi pyaar aur himmat se nayi shuruaat ho sakti hai.

Negative Points:

▪︎ Ambiguous Plot: Bache ke origin aur Aarav ke dost ke plan ka explanation thoda unclear hai. Yeh kaise plan kiya gaya aur kyun ispe aur detail chahiye tha.

▪︎ Weak Backstory: Aarav ke purane dost ka motive aur uski kahani ko zyada explore nahi kiya gaya jisse twist thoda rushed aur incomplete laga.

▪︎ Abrupt Ending: Climax mein bache ke asli father ka reveal jaldi ho jata hai aur uske baad kahani ka resolution thoda flat hai thoda aur buildup isse aur impactful bana sakta tha.

▪︎ Lack of Supporting Characters: Neha aur Aarav ke alawa koi aur character nahi hai jisse kahani mein variety ki kami lagti hai. Ek do side characters plot ko aur rich kar sakte the.

Ek Acchi Kahani ke Liye Kya Accha aur Kya Bura Hai:

▪︎ Accha: Ek acchi kahani mein emotional depth, gripping plot aur unexpected twists hona zaroori hai is kahani mein Neha-Aarav ka pyaar, suspenseful opening aur bache ka raaz yeh qualities puri karta hai. Simple bhasha aur fast-paced storytelling bhi iski taakat hai.

▪︎ Bura: Kahani ko aur mazboot karne ke liye clear plot explanations, well-rounded backstories aur satisfying climax chahiye is kahani mein kuch plot points ka vagueness aur rushed ending thodi kamzori hai.

Wartani aur Rhythm:

▪︎ Wartani: Kahani ki bhasha simple aur roman Hindi mein hai jo padhne mein asaan aur dilchasp hai. Dialogues emotional aur realistic hain.

▪︎ Rhythm: Kahani ka flow shuruaat mein bohot smooth aur engaging hai khaas kar shaadi ki raat aur hospital scene mein lekin investigation aur climax ke parts thoda jaldi wrapup ho jate hain jisse thodi depth miss hoti hai. Overall rhythm acha hai, par climax mein thoda balance chahiye tha.

Final Thoughts:

Ek chhoti, emotional aur suspenseful kahani hai jo romance aur mystery ke shauqeen readers ke liye ek accha option hai. Neha-Aarav ka rishta aur bache ka raaz kahani ko rochak banata hai lekin thodi aur clarity aur detailed climax isse aur behtar kar sakta tha. Wartani simple aur rhythm fast hai bas ending mein thodi polishing ki zarurat hai.
 

Bulbul_Rani

Well-Known Member
2,188
1,535
143
"Bevafa Bulbul" by Bulbul_Rani

Akash ki kahani hai jo apni patni Bulbul ke avaidh sambandhon ke bare mein ek gumnam phone se khabar paata hai. Shuru mein usse yakeen nahi hota lekin shak ke chalte woh apni patni ki harakaton par nazar rakhta hai aur akhir mein usse rang-e-haath pakad leta hai. Kahani is baat ki khoj hai ki Akash is dhokhe ka samna kaise karta hai aur apne bete ke bhavishya ke liye kya faisla leta hai.

Positive Points:

▪︎ Bhavnatmak Gehrai: Kahani mein ek pati ke dard, shak aur apman ko bahut gehrai se dikhaya gaya hai. Akash ka manovaigyanik sangharsh padhne wale ke dil ko chhoo jata hai.

▪︎ Vastavik Charitra: Akash, Bulbul aur doosre charitra bahut real lagte hain. Unke dialogues aur reactions aam zindagi se jude hue hain jo kahani ko aur prabhavshali banate hain.

▪︎ Samajik Mudda: Patni ki bewafai aur uska parivar par asar jaise vishay ko kahani mein sensitively uthaya gaya hai. Yeh samajik sachchai ko darshata hai.

▪︎ Antim Faisla: Akash ka apne bete ke liye talak na lene ka faisla kahani ko ek vyavharik aur bhavuk mod deta hai jo padhne wale ko sochne par majboor karta hai.

Negative Points:

▪︎ Ek Tarafa Drishtikon: Kahani mein Bulbul ke charitra ko poori tarah se vikas nahi kiya gaya. Uska bewafai ka karan ya uski manasthiti ko aur gehrai se dikhaya ja sakta tha taaki padhne wale ko uske liye bhi thodi sah-anubhuti ho.

▪︎ Bar-bar Dhruvikaran: Akash ke shak aur chhupkar ghar aane ke drishya kuch zyada hi dohraye gaye hain jo kahani ke rhythm ko thoda slow kar dete hain.

▪︎ Gumnam Caller ka Rahasya: Phone karne wale ka asli uddeshya ya pehchan akhir tak anjaan rehti hai jo kahani mein ek adhoora pan deta hai.

▪︎ Kuch Sankshipt Drishya: Neerav ki patni Reema aur Bulbul ke pita ke saath Akash ke samvad thode jaldi khatam ho jate hain. In drishyon ko thoda aur vistar diya ja sakta tha.

Ek Acchi Kahani ke Liye Kya Accha aur Kya Bura:

▪︎ Accha: Ek acchi kahani mein charitron ka vikas, bhavnatmak gehrai aur ek prabhavshali sandesh hona chahiye. "Bevafa Bulbul" is mamle mein kaafi had tak safal hai kyunki yeh parivarik sambandhon aur vishwasghat ke dard ko ujaagar karti hai.

▪︎ Bura: Kahani mein har charitra ke drishtikon ko barabar dikhana zaroori hota hai. Is kahani mein Bulbul ke charitra ko thoda aur vikas ki zaroorat thi. Saath hi kuch drishyon ka bar-bar dohrav aur thodi si lambai rhythm ko toda sa kamzor karti hai.

Vartani aur Rhythm:

▪︎ Vartani: Kahani ki bhasha saral hai Hindi ke aam shabdon ka istemal kiya gaya hai jo padhne mein asaan hai. Kuch jagah shabdon ka dohrav thoda zyada lagta hai lekin vartani mein koi badi galti nahi hai.

▪︎ Rhythm: Kahani ka rhythm shuru mein kaafi accha hai jab Akash ke shak aur uski chhupkar ghar aane ki koshish suspense paida karti hai lekin beech mein kuch drishya lambey ho jate hain jo thodi si udaasi paida karte hain antim hissa bhavuk aur prabhavshali hai jo rhythm ko dobara tezi deta hai.

Overall:

"Bevafa Bulbul" ek bhavuk aur vicharneey kahani hai jo bewafai aur parivarik jivan ke sangharsh ko darshati hai. Yeh kahani apne bhavnatmak drishyon aur Akash ke faisle ke saath dil ko chhooti hai lekin kuch charitron ka adhoora vikas aur thodi lambai iski kami hain thodi si editing aur doosre charitron ke drishtikon ko shamil karke ise aur prabhavshali banaya ja sakta tha.
Thanks dear akash
 

Bulbul_Rani

Well-Known Member
2,188
1,535
143
Writer : Bulbul_Rani
Story genre - Adultery
Story line -पत्नी (बुलबुल)की बेवफाई जानने के बाद, एक आदमी (आकाश)जासूस की मदद से सच्चाई का पता लगाता है। कहानी में रिश्ते, धोखा और परिवार के बारे में दिखाया गया है।

Positive point

* Pace : कहानी तेजी से आगे बढ़ती है, जिससे पाठक बंधा रहता है। रहस्य और तनाव बना रहता है क्योंकि आकाश सच्चाई को उजागर करने की कोशिश करता है।

* Character development: मुख्य पात्रों, विशेष रूप से आकाश को अच्छी तरह से विकसित किया गया है। उनकी भावनाएं और संघर्ष वास्तविक लगते हैं, जिससे पाठक उनसे जुड़ पाते हैं।

* depth of the subject :कहानी बेवफाई, विश्वासघात और पारिवारिक संबंधों की जटिलताओं जैसे गंभीर विषयों को छूती है। यह पाठकों को रिश्तों की प्रकृति और उनके टूटने के परिणामों के बारे में सोचने पर मजबूर करती है।

* Social relevance : कहानी भारतीय समाज में विवाह और पारिवारिक मूल्यों से संबंधित मुद्दों पर प्रकाश डालती है, जिससे यह कई पाठकों के लिए प्रासंगिक बन जाती है।


Negativee point

* One sided approach : कहानी मुख्य रूप से आकाश के दृष्टिकोण से बताई गई है, जिससे बुलबुल के कार्यों के पीछे की पूरी कहानी समझने में कमी लगती है।

* Unrealistic element : जिस आसानी से आकाश को एक जासूस मिल जाता है और जिस तेजी से जासूस सबूत इकट्ठा कर लेता है, वह थोड़ा अवास्तविक है। वास्तविक जीवन में, ऐसी जाँचें अधिक जटिल और समय लेने वाली हो सकती हैं।


Short verdict:
यह कहानी रिश्तों में धोखे और उसके नतीजों के बारे में है। इसमें प्यार, गुस्सा, और परिवार की अहमियत दिखाई गई है। कहानी थोड़ी उलझन भरी है, लेकिन यह सोचने पर मजबूर करती है कि रिश्तों में क्या सही और क्या गलत होता है। अगर आप रिश्तों की गहराई में जाना चाहते हैं, तो यह कहानी आपके लिए है।

Overall it's a good story
Rating 6/10
Thanks you so much sir
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: Shetan and Avaran

Aakash.

ɪ'ᴍ ᴜꜱᴇᴅ ᴛᴏ ʙᴇ ꜱᴡᴇᴇᴛ ᴀꜱ ꜰᴜᴄᴋ, ɴᴏᴡ ɪᴛ'ꜱ ꜰᴜᴄᴋ & ꜰᴜᴄᴋ
Staff member
Sr. Moderator
50,943
163,122
354
"Jeevon ka Karun Krandan" by satrangi muniya

Prernadayak aur emotional kahani hai jo jungle ke jeevon ke dard aur sangharsh ko darshati hai jab unka aashiyana ko jungle katne se khatra hota hai. Sunita Morni, Veena Toti, Chatur Bandar aur Durga Sher jaise characters ke zariye yeh kahani paryavaran sanrakshan aur jeevon ke adhikaron ka powerful sandesh deti hai. Kahani dil ko chhuti hai aur samajik muddon par sochne ko majboor karti hai.

Positive Points:

▪︎ Strong Message: Kahani ka kendriya vichar paryavaran aur jeevon ka sanrakshan bohot relevant aur prernadayak hai. Yeh readers ko jungle ke mahatva aur insaani laparwahi ke prabhav ke baare mein sochne par majboor karta hai.

▪︎ Relatable Characters: Sunita Morni, Veena Toti aur Chatur Bandar jaise characters apni sadi si baaton aur dar se relatable hain. Durga Sher ka leadership aur Chatur ki buddhi kahani ko mazedaar banati hai.

▪︎ Emotional Depth: Jeevon ka karun krandan jaise Sunita ka apne bacchon ke liye dar ya Veena ka amrud ke ped ke chinta kahani ko emotionally engaging banata hai.

▪︎ Social Awareness: Kahani mein social media aur animal rights organizations ke zariye jeevon ki awaaz uthane ka concept modern aur impactful hai.

▪︎ Hopeful Ending: Jungle ki katai par rok aur jeevon ke punarvaas ka positive resolution kahani ko ummeed se bhar deta hai jo satisfying hai.

Negative Points:

▪︎ Over-Simplified Resolution: Jungle katai par court stay aur punarvaas ka solution thoda idealistic aur jaldi wrap-up laga is process ko thoda realistic dikhaya ja sakta tha.

▪︎ Limited Character Depth: Characters jaise Shamsher Cheetah ya Bhola Hiran ke motives ya backstories zyada explore nahi kiye gaya jisse woh thode one-dimensional lagte hain.

▪︎ Repetitive Dialogues: Kuch scenes mein jeevon ka rona ya chinta bar-bar repeat hoti hai jo kahani ko thoda slow kar deta hai.

▪︎ Undeveloped Human Angle: Varun aur uski sanstha ka role thoda sudden introduce hota hai. Human characters ko thoda aur develop kiya ja sakta tha taaki jeevon aur insaanon ka connection aur gehra ho.

Ek Acchi Kahani ke Liye Kya Accha aur Kya Bura Hai:

▪︎ Accha: Ek acchi kahani mein strong message, relatable characters aur emotional connect zaroori hai is kahani mein paryavaran ka mudda, jeevon ka dard aur hopeful ending yeh qualities puri karta hai. Simple bhasha aur vivid jungle scenes bhi plus point hain.

▪︎ Bura: Kahani ko aur impactful banane ke liye realistic resolutions, well-developed characters aur balanced pacing chahiye us kahani mein climax ka idealism aur kuch repetitive parts thodi kamzori hain.

Wartani aur Rhythm:

▪︎ Wartani: Kahani ki bhasha simple aur Hindi mein hai jo padhne mein asaan aur dilchasp hai. Dialogues natural hain khaas kar jeevon ki chinta wale scenes mein. Spelling mein koi major galti nahi hai.

▪︎ Rhythm: Kahani ka flow shuruaat mein acha hai khaas kar Sunita aur Veena ke scenes mein. Meeting scene mein thodi repetitiveness se pace slow hoti hai lekin climax fast aur satisfying hai.

Final Thoughts:

Emotional aur samajik mudde par aadharit kahani hai jo paryavaran sanrakshan ka zaroori sandesh deti hai. Sunita, Veena aur Chatur jaise characters aur jungle ka vivid description kahani ko dilchasp banate hain lekin thoda realistic climax aur character depth isse aur behtar kar sakta tha. Wartani simple aur rhythm acha hai bas kuch scenes mein thodi polishing chahiye.
 
Top